Book Review: Our Darkest Night by Jennifer Robson #theOCBookGirl

Welcome Back, Readers!

Today’s review is a new historical fiction title. Jennifer Robson’s compelling sixth novel centers on a young Italian Jewish woman living in disguise during World War II.

Title: Our Darkest Night

Author: Jennifer Robson

Genre: Historical Fiction, WWII

Published: January 5, 2021

Source: Kathleen Carter Communications

My Thoughts:

This is a difficult book to review, partially because any story set during WWII is going to be dark and heartbreaking.

Sadly, I didn’t connect with the characters to feel real empathy despite the atrocities being described. It felt disjointed and didn’t flow for me. It was too up and down and the ending seemed a little far fetched.

Aside from the very beginning when Nina’s father tells her it’s okay to eat non kosher food, the first 20 chapters don’t really address her religion at all or the toll it takes on her spiritually to have to hide her faith. It’s more about her having to get used to backbreaking physical work on the farm and how nice and polite and kind Nico is. It’s set up from the beginning that he will be the protective hero and they will fall in love.

When the Germans arrive on the scene, it turns into a completely different book. It was emotionally stressful and brutal to read about what she endures and I believe that’s intentional.

I appreciated the authors note at the end where she states that she imagines Nina and her family to be “ethnically and culturally Jewish, but in their religious practices they were not especially observant.” That helped me understand Nina’s apathy.

The author’s husband’s family is the basis for some of the characters and storylines. There is some evidence that they did in fact help families escape the Nazi’s which is an amazing legacy to honor and it’s obvious how much research the author put in to setting the place and time.

I wish I had connected more to the characters but it’s still a dramatic and exciting story. I’m looking forward to reading more by this author. | Goodreads


To survive the Holocaust, a young Jewish woman must pose as a Christian farmer’s wife in this unforgettable novel from USA Today bestselling author Jennifer Robson–a story of terror, hope, love, and sacrifice, inspired by true events, that vividly evokes the most perilous days of World War II.

It is the autumn of 1943, and life is becoming increasingly perilous for Italian Jews like the Mazin family. With Nazi Germany now occupying most of her beloved homeland, and the threat of imprisonment and deportation growing ever more certain, Antonina Mazin has but one hope to survive–to leave Venice and her beloved parents and hide in the countryside with a man she has only just met.

Nico Gerardi was studying for the priesthood until circumstances forced him to leave the seminary to run his family’s farm. A moral and just man, he could not stand by when the fascists and Nazis began taking innocent lives. Rather than risk a perilous escape across the mountains, Nina will pose as his new bride. And to keep her safe and protect secrets of his own, Nico and Nina must convince prying eyes they are happily married and in love.

But farm life is not easy for a cultured city girl who dreams of becoming a doctor like her father, and Nico’s provincial neighbors are wary of this soft and educated woman they do not know. Even worse, their distrust is shared by a local Nazi official with a vendetta against Nico. The more he learns of Nina, the more his suspicions grow–and with them his determination to exact revenge.

As Nina and Nico come to know each other, their feelings deepen, transforming their relationship into much more than a charade. Yet both fear that every passing day brings them closer to being torn apart …

About the Author:

Jennifer Robson: An academic by background, a former editor by profession, and a lifelong history nerd, I am lucky enough to now call myself a full-time writer. I’m the author of six novels set during and after the two world wars: Somewhere in France, After the War is Over, Moonlight Over Paris, Goodnight from London, The Gown, and Our Darkest Night: A Novel of Italy and the Second World War. I was also a contributor to the acclaimed anthology Fall of Poppies: Stories of Love and the Great War.

I studied French literature and Modern History as an undergraduate at King’s University College at Western University, then attended Saint Antony’s College at the University of Oxford, where I obtained my doctorate in British economic and social history. While at Oxford I was a Commonwealth Scholar and SSHRC Doctoral Fellow.

I am represented by Kevan Lyon of the Marsal Lyon Agency and my personal publicist is Kathleen Carter of Kathleen Carter Communications.

I live in Toronto, Canada, with my husband and children, and share my home office with Ellie the sheepdog and her feline companions Sam and Mika.

Did you enjoy this post? Please take a few seconds and click to retweet! [bctt tweet=”Book Review: Our Darkest Night by Jennifer Robson #theOCBookGirl”]

Let’s be friends! The OC BookGirl is on Goodreads, Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook.

Thank you for supporting this blog and the books I recommend! This post may contain affiliate links, which means I receive compensation if you make a purchase using this link. I may have received a book for free in exchange for my honest review, however, all opinions are my own.

If you want to purchase any books I’ve mentioned, please search my online bookstore: (Find and support your local bookstore using this link.) 

One comment

Comments are closed.